Use promo code SWEATERWEATHER and get 50% off your first 2 months

Increase productivity and reduce cost by leveling up design quality

Actionable

design

critique

has

arrived

Unlimited requests. Unlimited insights. Unlimited improvement. One Flat Rate.

Availability open

A design agency, but for feedback

The other half of design is critique. We'll do the other half.

"It's through mistakes that you actually can grow. You have to get bad in order to get good."

Paula headshot
Paula Scher
Partner at Pentagram

"Critique is not a ‘nice-to-have’ in the design process."

Peter headshot
Peter Merholz
Humanism at Scale

"Someone who thinks 'I like it' means 'Its good' is not a good critic of design."

Brandon headshot
Brandon Moore
moorecreativ.design

Better design has never been easier

Sign up

Snag a full service monthly membership that works best for you, pause at anytime, and start today

Make a request

Upload or link your designs and get quick feedback from seasoned professional designers

Get takeaways

Receive a scorecard packed with practical insights for leveling up your work the very next business day

One critique reviewed three times

Understanding

The first cycle is a high level scan of your overall design to understand its purpose and capture immediate emotional response

Aesthetics

The second cycle dives deep into the visual presentation of the work, measuring eight specific visual design heuristics

Functionality

The third cycle completes the scorecard by measuring core usability mechanics, accessibility, and learnabilty

Membership benefits

We’ll be your in-house professional design editing team that continually elevates your quality while saving you time and (more importantly) money

icon
Save time asynchronously
Longwinded team meetings and daily Slack distractions waste valuable production time. We handle your requests, sans the frivolous chatter.
icon
Reduce your cost
Measure twice, cut once. Continually check your design quality and eliminate expensive development rework and customer complaints.
icon
Shrink your feedback loop
No more waiting around for the weekly design team critique, or watching for notifications. Get your actionable insights tomorrow.
icon
Make unlimited requests
We’ll keep your feedback engine running continually, one request at a time, with no limitations or additional costs.
icon
Invite your whole team
Add all your team members to your request queue so everyone can improve their output quality and design skills.
icon
Pause at anytime
Pause your subscription anytime your want for as long as you want. We’ll always be right here waiting for you to return.

Unlock exceptional design quality

Aesthetic Scorecard

Our detailed critique is broken down into two core heuristic sections; Form and Function. The aesthetic review encompasses a thoughtful eight point review of the overall visual presentation of the project.

Consistency, Standards, Legibility

Composition, Layout, Visual Hierarchy

Balance & Contrast

Space, Size, Alignment, Gestalt

Visual Relevance & Impact

"Presentation is important because it is the first thing that we perceive and it can make or break someone’s appetite."
Thomas headshot
Thomas Keller
Chef/Owner, The French Laundry

Functional Scorecard

The eight point functional scorecard evaluates overall efficiency, usability, and mechanical quality of your work. In addition, we'll score the project against your design system guidelines.

Ease of Use, Progressive Disclosure

System Communication, Error Prevention, Recovery

Recall & Learnability

Workflows, Interactions, Overall Mechanics

Usability Relevance & Impact

What designs can be Critiqued?

If your using...

Figma
Procreate
Affinity
Sketch
Canva
Illustrator
Keynote
Photoshop
Indesign
CorelDRAW
Marvel
UXPin
GIMP
Inkscape
Anything

... export it to PNG, JPG, or PDF we'll critique it.

  • Websites, mobile apps, desktop apps, SaaS, icons, component libraries, design systems, graphics, data tables, user interfaces, dashboards, gaming interfaces, and more.

  • Logos, branding, brand guides, illustrations, social media, landing pages, posters, ads, trade show materials, stickers, labels, cereal boxes, packaging, and more.

  • Slide decks, presentations, reports, booklets, business cards, proposals, swag, email graphics, resumes, portfolios, internal newsletters, and more.

Flat rate monthly subscriptions

Get started with an on-demand monthly plan that fits your team best.
Pause at anytime.

SMALL TEAMS
$899.99
/ month

Flat monthly price. Pause anytime.

  • Up to 5 members
  • Unlimited critiques
  • High priority delivery
  • Custom style guides
  • One request at a time
MEDIUM TEAMS
$1899.99
/ month

Flat monthly price. Pause anytime.

  • Up to 10 members
  • Unlimited critiques
  • High priority delivery
  • Custom style guides
  • One request at a time
LARGE TEAMS
$2899.99
/ month

Flat monthly price. Pause anytime.

  • 11+ members
  • Unlimited critiques
  • High priority delivery
  • Custom style guides
  • One request at a time
FREELANCE & CONTRACTOR
$199.99
/ month
  • One member
  • Unlimited critiques
  • All team package features included

Commonly asked questions

How would this service save me money?
Who will be reviewing my designs?
What happens after I sign up?
How are the critique results sent to me?
How do I submit my designs and style guides?
Do you have student discounts?
How would I pause my subscription?
Can my designers submit their own requests?
How many images can I submit for each request?
What does "high priority delivery" actually mean?
What does "custom style guide" mean?
Can I get a refund if I don’t like the service?